PROPER 14, YEAR A
Sunday 9 August 2026
Sts. Matthew and Mark, Barrington, R. I.
1 Kings 19:9-18
Matthew 14:22-33
The Old Testament and Gospel readings appointed for today both feature awesome natural phenomena: in the first instance, wind, earthquake, and fire on a mountain; in the second instance, a squall of wind and waves on the sea. Both Elijah in the cave on Mount Horeb and the disciples in the boat on the Sea of Galilee are in fear for their lives. In both cases, however, these terrifying disturbances of nature give way to calm, signaling divine reassurance and peace.
In the first reading, the prophet Elijah has slain 450 priests of Baal at Mount Carmel in northern Israel. He has then fled from the wicked queen Jezebel, who understandably seeks his life. After forty days of traveling south through the wilderness, he arrives at Horeb, the mountain of God. This is generally believed to be the same as Mount Sinai, where Moses first encountered God at the burning bush and later received God’s Law many centuries before.
By coming here, Elijah is returning to the roots of Israel’s religion, seeking answers, trying to understand. We might even say that he’s undergoing a crisis of faith. When God asks why he’s come, Elijah complains: “I have been very zealous for the Lord, the God of hosts; for the Israelites have forsaken your covenant, thrown down your altars, and killed your prophets with the sword. I alone am left, and they are seeking my life, to take it away.” So, the pyrotechnics begin: first a violent wind that breaks the rocks in pieces, then an earthquake, and then fire. But the Lord is not in the wind, earthquake, or fire. Then, in the “sheer silence” that follows, God speaks.
The Lord reassures Elijah that, appearances to the contrary, all is not lost. He must return and anoint new kings of Syria and Israel, and a new prophet, Elisha, to be his successor. For God has preserved seven thousand in Israel who have not bowed the knee to Baal. From this faithful remnant God will make a new beginning for the nation in true worship and obedience to God’s law. It’s a wonderful passage. I find it a source of great reassurance in our own time, when religious observance seems to be in perilous decline.
Saint Matthew’s account of Jesus walking upon the Sea of Galilee also describes a crisis of faith. This episode is found in three of the canonical Gospels—Matthew, Mark, and John—but only Matthew includes the story of Peter getting out of the boat and attempting to walk over the waves to Jesus.
To begin with, the disciples are afraid of the wind and waves battering the boat by night. They could easily be swamped and drown in the stormy sea. Then, when they see Jesus approaching them, they’re terrified, thinking that they’re seeing a ghost: a nocturnal maritime portent of impending doom. But he reassures them, “Take heart, it is I; do not be afraid.”
In the part of the story unique to Matthew, ever impetuous Peter answers, “Lord, if it is you, command me to come to you on the water.” Jesus gamely replies, “All right then, come on.” So Peter gets out of the boat and walks to Jesus. All goes well until Peter’s faith falters. He becomes afraid and begins to sink, crying out, “Lord, save me!” Jesus reaches out and takes hold of Peter, reproving him, “You of little faith, why did you doubt?” When they get into the boat, the wind ceases. And the disciples in the boat worship Jesus, acclaiming him as the Son of God.
While these two stories are very different in both setting and narrative detail, they do share a few structural similarities. Both describe a journey. In both cases, the journey represents a quest for a closer encounter with God and divine reassurance in a time of crisis. And then, Peter’s sinking beneath the waves and crying out, “Lord, save me!” loosely parallels Elijah’s complaint, “I alone am left, and they are seeking my life, to take it away.”
In both cases, moreover, the really significant divine-human communication takes place in the calm following the storm: God speaks to Elijah in the sound of sheer silence; the disciples in the boat on the becalmed sea worship Jesus and confess that he is truly the Son of God. In both cases, finally, the end result is a return: the Lord sends Elijah back to Israel by way of the wilderness of Damascus to fulfill his prophetic vocation; Jesus and the disciples disembark on the shore to continue their mission in Galilee.
The Gospel symbolism of the boat is significant. One of the earliest Christian emblems of the Church was that of a boat or ship. Early Christian readers would likely have recognized the boat battered by the waves as an image of the Church suffering persecution. This sense is even clearer in the Greek, where Matthew says that the boat is being “tormented” or “tortured” by the waves.
By walking over the sea to his disciples, Jesus confirms that he is indeed the lord of heaven and earth. His words, “it is I”—in Greek, egō eimi—can be literally translated as “I am,” the Old Testament name of God. The symbolism is that of the Lord coming to his Church’s aid as it suffers persecution in a frightening and dangerous world—much as God came to Elijah’s aid when Israel’s faith and worship seemed on the verge of being stamped out by Queen Jezebel and the priests of Baal.
One final detail: notice that once Jesus rescues Peter, the two of them don’t continue walking together over the sea towards the shore. Rather, Jesus brings Peter back to the boat. They both get in, the wind ceases, and the disciples in the boat worship Jesus as the Son of God.
A great temptation for Christians down through the centuries has been to think that we can have a special relationship with Jesus by going it alone—apart from the Church’s worship, teaching, sacraments, and fellowship. But Jesus brings Peter back to the boat; just as God sends Elijah back to the people of Israel.
Perhaps, then, the deepest lesson of this Gospel is not that “we too can walk on the water if only we have enough faith,” but rather that real faith requires us to stay in the boat, or if we’ve left it, to get back in! Trying to be with Jesus by means of some individualistic do-it-yourself spirituality simply doesn’t work, at least not for long. Instead, we need to return to the boat—the ecclesial community of faith—for that is where we can absolutely rely on Jesus to come to us. And there we worship him as the Son of God in the calm that follows the storm.