PROPER 13, YEAR A
Sunday 2 August 2026
Sts. Matthew & Mark, Barrington, R. I.
Matthew 14:13-21
The feeding of the five thousand is one of the classic Gospel epiphanies or revelations of Jesus’ identity as the Son of God. This miracle is one of the few recorded in all four Gospels. And all four Evangelists—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—clearly present it as a miraculous event: five loaves and two fish multiply to feed five thousand people.
Now, somewhere along the line, you may have heard sermons that attempt to explain what really happened here as a “miracle of sharing.” According to that interpretation, when Jesus took, blessed, and distributed the five loaves and two fish, they didn’t really multiply to feed the five thousand and more who were present. As modern people, of course, we know that sort of thing doesn’t happen and can’t happen. Instead, the generosity of Jesus and the disciples sharing what they had inspired everyone present to bring out whatever food they’d brought with them and share it with their neighbors so that in the end everyone was fed. So, according to that interpretation, the real miracle was one of generosity and sharing.
With all due respect to the preachers who preach such misguided sermons, such an explanation belongs to a modern rationalist mindset, which rules out any possibility of the genuinely miraculous from the get-go. It certainly doesn’t belong to the biblical mindset. But if God is the sort of God the Church professes him to be, he can certainly multiply five loaves and two fish to feed a multitude—just as he can part the sea’s waters to let the Israelites cross over on dry ground, and just as he can raise those who have died to eternal life. So, we need not buy into such naturalistic interpretations. We need not be scandalized by the miraculous.
Another problem with the miracle-of-sharing interpretation is that it takes the focus off Jesus and places it on us. It replaces the Gospel of salvation by Christ with a Gospel of salvation by collective community self-help. It reduces Christ to a teacher who sets an example for us to follow. The problem is that we don’t need a teacher and example nearly as much as we need a Lord and Savior. And a Jesus who can multiply five loaves and two fish to feed a multitude of over five thousand men, plus women and children, is clearly the Savior of the world and the Lord of the universe.
Now, having got that out of the way, let’s refocus our attention on the story itself. Matthew’s account shows an interesting interaction between Jesus and the disciples in responding to the crisis occasioned by the lack of food. The disciples initially identify the problem. It’s getting late, and they’re in a remote place. So the disciples approach Jesus and ask him to send the crowds away to the villages round about so that they can buy food for themselves.
In response, Jesus issues the command: “They need not go away; you give them something to eat.” A similar pattern often obtains in the Christian life: We perceive a need; we take it to Jesus and tell him what we think he ought to do about it; and he responds by telling us what he wants us to do about it!
The disciples protest: “We have only five loaves here, and two fish.” But Jesus is unfazed. He s answers: “Bring them here to me.” Even though it’s well within his power as the Son of God to create loaves of bread from the rocks lying on the ground, he chooses instead to make full use of what the disciples have to offer. They must offer all that they have, holding nothing back. All five loaves and two fish: nothing less will do.
What I find enormously comforting and reassuring in this story is that it’s precisely the gifts that the disciples actually have that Jesus works with. He doesn’t fault them for not having brought more. The five loaves and two fish will do just fine. Nothing less will do, but nothing more is needed.
So, in the end, all eat and are satisfied. Those fed number five thousand men, besides women and children. The miracle shows God at work, doing what only God can do. But, apart from the immediate purpose of responding to the crisis at hand and feeding the hungry people, does it have any deeper meaning?
Well, first, notice the twelve baskets of fragments left over. These point to both the twelve tribes of Israel and the twelve apostles. In the future, after the Lord’s death and resurrection, the twelve apostles will be sent into the world to preach the Gospel to all nations. The twelve baskets signify that they will carry a superabundance of Word and Sacraments to feed all who hunger and thirst for God.
The English Dominican theologian Aidan Nichols writes that the deepest signification of the feeding of the five thousand is God’s decision to give himself as food for humanity. The multiplication of the loaves and fishes depicts Jesus as a new Moses, feeding the multitudes in the desert with bread from heaven.
At the same time, Matthew’s depiction of Jesus’ actions—taking, giving thanks, breaking and distributing—anticipates what he does at the Last Supper. The Church carries these four actions forward into the Christian Eucharist. Here we take, give thanks over, break, and distribute the bread, which truly becomes Christ’s Body. And here we take, give thanks over, pour out, and distribute the wine, which truly becomes his Blood. And just as the feeding of the five thousand points beyond itself to the Eucharist, so the Eucharist points beyond itself to the messianic banquet that awaits us in the life of the world to come.
As Nichols puts it: “Ultimately, the [miracle] of God feeding us with himself will happen in the future, in glory, when by the Holy Spirit we shall see the exalted Jesus Christ face to face as who he is—God from God, but in a human form, in a humanly accessible way. We shall see him as God’s very life poured out for us and into us, and we shall be supremely satisfied by that vision.”