PROPER 25, YEAR C
October 26, 2025
Saints Matthew and Mark, Barrington, R. I.
Sirach 35:12-17
Psalm 84:1-6
2 Timothy 4:6-8, 16-18
Luke 18:9-14
Jesus told this parable to some who trusted in themselves that they were righteous and regarded others with contempt … The parable in today’s Gospel contrasts two characters who occupied positions poles apart: a Pharisee and a tax collector.
The Pharisees have received somewhat bad press in the Christian Church down through the centuries. But this parable’s original hearers would have held them in high regard. Away from the religious establishment centered in the Temple of Jerusalem and its priesthood, the Pharisees constituted a popular movement in Israel’s towns and villages, dedicated to keeping the Jewish Law amid the mundane occupations and activities of everyday life.
But this does not mean the Pharisees opposed the Temple system. On the contrary, like all good Jews, they made pilgrimages to Jerusalem to offer sacrifice and prayer whenever they could. Their attitude might be expressed in the lines of today’s Psalm: “How dear to me is your dwelling, Lord God of hosts; my heart has a desire and longing for the courts of the Lord … Happy the people … whose hearts are set on the pilgrims’ way … They will climb from height to height, and the God of gods will reveal himself in Zion.”
So, in today’s Gospel, a Pharisee goes up to the Temple to pray. His prayer mentions two practices characteristic of the Pharisees’ spirituality: fasting twice a week and giving a tenth of all his income, also known as tithing. On first hearing this parable, the original audience would immediately have identified the Pharisee as the story’s good guy.
And we shouldn’t be too quick to assume otherwise. The Pharisee’s attitude embodies the verse in today’s Old Testament reading from Sirach: “Give to the Most High as he has given to you, and as generously as you can afford.” And if we’re tempted to condemn him for being boastful, well, he’s no more boastful than Saint Paul, who writes in today’s Epistle: “I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith.”
If our Lord’s original audience regarded the Pharisee as upright and virtuous, they certainly assumed precisely the opposite of the tax collector. In first-century Palestine, tax collectors were condemned as collaborators with the Roman occupiers. Moreover, they were not government employees but independent contractors. The Romans awarded the right to collect taxes to the highest bidder, who would then have to pay for the contract up front. Tax collectors thus had an enormous incentive to recoup their investment by fraud and extortion. Hence, they were reviled as notorious sinners, beyond the pale of respectable society, much as we regard drug traffickers or pimps today.
Now, when I’ve preached on this parable in the past, I’ve followed conventional New Testament scholarship in describing the ending as a “great reversal.” The tax collector, rather than the Pharisee, goes down to his house justified—that is, having found favor with God. Such an outcome would have turned all the hearers’ expectations and assumptions upside down in a shocking and scandalous way. How could a tax collector, rather than a Pharisee, be the one who gains God’s vindication?
However, the Jewish New Testament scholar Amy-Jill Levine proposes a surprisingly different interpretation. She points out that in the final sentence, the Greek word para, here translated “instead of” or “rather than,” might better be rendered “alongside” or “together with.” In that case, the tax collector went down to his house justified, as well as the Pharisee. Contrary to the traditional reading, the Pharisee is not condemned. But the real shock of the parable is that neither is the tax collector. They both return home having found favor with God.
The great temptation in this parable for some Christian readers—especially those coming from a more Reformed or Protestant tradition—is to conclude that Jesus is condemning such practices as fasting and tithing, which they identify as “works righteousness.” That is the very last interpretation that I want to encourage, especially at the time of our Stewardship Program! Jesus himself fasted and prayed, and taught his followers to do the same. Moreover, he also called his disciples to give away not merely a tenth of their income, but all their possessions. The parable is not against fasting and tithing per se, but against trusting in oneself that one is righteous and despising others.
The Pharisee’s problem lies not in his spiritual practices, which are entirely good and praiseworthy. Contrary to centuries of antisemitic interpretation of this parable, there’s nothing self-righteous or hypocritical in his attitude. Thanking God for his ability to lead this life, the Pharisee implicitly acknowledges that his righteousness comes from God and not from himself. But his one blind spot, the one point where he needs to be humbled to be exalted, lies in his contempt for others: “I am not like other people: thieves, rogues, adulterers, or even this tax collector.”
Conversely, the tax collector’s one virtue is that he knows better than to trust in himself. He’s such a sinner that he can do nothing to merit God’s forgiveness. God alone can take away his guilt. And so he pleads, “God, be merciful to me, a sinner!”
At this point, Amy-Jill Levine makes a remarkable suggestion. The tax collector returns home forgiven precisely on account of the Pharisee’s righteousness. What the Pharisee fails to recognize is that his spiritual achievements are not solely for his own benefit. They generate a surplus of merit, in which even the tax collector can share. So the Pharisee and the tax collector both return home, blessed by God.
If this interpretation is accurate, then the parable expresses the biblical theology of the faithful remnant, in which the fidelity of a few obtains the salvation of the many. In today’s Epistle, Saint Paul describes his own faithfulness as not only for his own benefit but also for those for whom he labors: “From now on there is reserved for me the crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous judge, will give me on that day, and not only to me but to all who have longed for his appearing.” The essence of the Christian Gospel is the good news that the fidelity and obedience of one man, Jesus Christ, suffices to obtain God’s forgiveness for a fallen and sinful world.
This parable’s point, then, is not that there’s anything wrong with the traditional spiritual disciplines. Fasting, prayer, almsgiving, and works of mercy are indispensable to growing in the knowledge and love of God, and becoming more and more the people God has created us to be, to his glory.
The one temptation we need to beware of, however, is that of looking down on others. In an era of declining church attendance and religious observance, our calling is to be a faithful remnant. We come here to offer our worship and prayer, our faithfulness and obedience, precisely on behalf of those who aren’t here, so that, in ways unknown to us, they also may find favor with God.