SOCIETY OF MARY ANNUAL MASS
Saturday, October 17, 2026
St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, Troy, NY
Interest in and devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary are growing in the Episcopal Church and across the wider Anglican world. It’s no longer just an Anglo-Catholic thing. Parishes of all kinds of churchmanship have Rosary groups and Walsingham cells.
In this context, I find it interesting to see which aspects of our Lady resonate most with writers and preachers who’ve recently discovered her. Often, their focus is on Mary’s response to the angel’s message at the Annunciation. Her humility, trust, obedience, and active cooperation with God’s plan seem to be the very model of Christian discipleship, and rightly so.
Nonetheless, a full and balanced Marian devotion will make room for Mary's other appearances in Scripture, Tradition, and the Church’s ongoing life. To be clear: Mary is one and the same person throughout. Yet at different times and in different places, she presents herself to us in different ways.
In the opening chapters of St. Luke’s Gospel, she’s the Virgin of Nazareth. In the nineteenth chapter of St. John’s Gospel, she’s the Sorrowful Mother at the foot of the cross. In the first chapter of Acts, she becomes the Mother of the Church, praying with the disciples in the Upper Room for the Holy Spirit’s descent. Finally, at the end of her earthly life, she falls asleep and is taken up, body and soul, to reign as Queen of heaven.
We Anglicans are fond of the Latin phrase lex orandi, lex credendi, “the law of prayer is the law of belief.” It suggests that the prayers and collects in our liturgies and devotions best express our distinctive doctrines. But I’ve recently become aware of another Latin saying: lex cantandi, lex credendi, “the law of singing (or chanting) is the law of belief.” In other words, our best hymns and anthems also powerfully express what we believe. I suspect many people in the pews learn more theology from the hymns they sing than from sermons, Bible studies, or Christian education classes.
One excellent hymn for teaching Marian theology is number 278 in The Hymnal 1982. The first verse begins: “Sing we of the blessed Mother, who received the angel’s word, and obedient to the summons, bore in love the infant Lord …” The second verse brings us to Calvary: “Sing we too, of Mary’s sorrows, of the sword that pierced her through, when beneath the cross of Jesus, she his weight of suffering knew …” The third verse brings us to the Resurrection and Pentecost: “Sing again the joys of Mary, when she saw the risen Lord, and in prayer with Christ’s apostles, waited on his promised word …” Finally, the fourth verse points us to heaven: “Sing the chiefest joy of Mary, when on earth her work was done, and the Lord of all creation, brought her to his heavenly home …”
The popular devotion known as the Holy Rosary likewise directs our attention to different aspects of Mary’s role in the drama of salvation. In its traditional form, it guides us through fifteen episodes from the lives of Mary and Jesus, grouped into three sets of five: the Joyful, Sorrowful, and Glorious Mysteries. Praying the Rosary helps us experience these mysteries from the perspective of Mary’s participation in her Son’s life and mission.
In the early eighteenth century, the French priest and writer St. Louis de Montfort wrote in his book The Secret of the Rosary that the Joyful, Sorrowful, and Glorious Mysteries correspond to an ancient understanding of the three ways of the spiritual life. Beginning around the fourth century, writers such as Evagrius Pontus and the Pseudo-Dionysius observed that progress toward spiritual maturity often follows a recognizable three-stage pattern. St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Bonaventure developed this idea in the medieval period, and St. John of the Cross elaborated on it in the sixteenth century.
The traditional names for the three stages are the Purgative Way, the Illuminative Way, and the Unitive Way.
Those in the first stage are known as “beginners.” This is the stage of initial conversion: turning away from sin and toward Christ. Overall, it’s a joyful time, marked by spiritual experiences of joy and delight.
Those in the second stage are known as “proficients.” The transition to this stage often takes the form of a crisis, a period of darkness and discouragement as the consolations and delights of the first stage fade and seem lost. The soul learns to persevere in the spiritual disciplines by following Christ on the Way of the Cross. In this stage, we deepen our knowledge of the mysteries of sin and redemption, death, resurrection, and the hope of eternal life. (In 1959, Martin Thornton titled one of his classic books Christian Proficiency because he believed most Anglican parishioners seeking spiritual direction are in this second stage.)
Those in the third stage are traditionally known as “the perfect”—not because they’re literally perfect or sinless, but because God’s love is perfecting them. The transition into this stage is often marked by an even more intense spiritual crisis, in which the soul may lose sight of its former theological certainties but nonetheless gradually becomes aware of God’s presence within, at the innermost core of its being. In this stage, we’re often drawn to silent contemplative prayer to experience a direct union with God beyond words and images. (An anonymous fourteenth-century English author described this in the title of the book, The Cloud of Unknowing.)
Most Christian spiritual writers emphasize that these three stages don’t always follow a linear sequence. Sometimes we experience all three simultaneously. Sometimes we find ourselves zigzagging back and forth, circling around and around, spiraling up and down among them.
St. Louis de Montfort related the mysteries of the Holy Rosary to these stages of the spiritual life. The Joyful Mysteries help us in the early stages, reminding us of the joy we feel when Christ first enters our lives. The Sorrowful Mysteries teach us to persevere in the Christian disciplines and follow the Way of the Cross. The Glorious Mysteries point us toward union with God and with one another, to which we’re all called as baptized Christians.
To avoid misunderstanding, I’m not saying we should pray only the mysteries of the Holy Rosary that seem to match the stage of spiritual life we think we’re in. For one thing, we’re likely to get that wrong, and we really need to discuss that sort of question with a competent spiritual director. I am saying that a healthy Marian spirituality will be balanced, focusing our attention on all aspects of Mary’s life, mission, and role in God’s plan of salvation: joyful, sorrowful, and glorious. And the mysteries will speak to us differently, depending on where we are in our spiritual journey.
In recent years, certain segments of the Church emphasizing what they call “radical hospitality” have popularized the cliché: “Whoever you are, and wherever you are in your journey, there’s a place at the table for you.” My point in this sermon is best expressed by modifying that saying as follows: Whoever you are, and wherever you are in your spiritual journey, there’s a mystery of the Holy Rosary that can speak directly to you. For there, the Blessed Virgin Mary will meet you where you are and lead you to her Son, Jesus Christ our Lord.